Most people watching Israeli politics focus on the loud stuff—the protests in Tel Aviv, the Gaza war, the endless coalition collapses. They miss the quieter, much more permanent shift happening behind closed doors. Over nearly two decades in power, Benjamin Netanyahu didn't just win elections. He fundamentally rewired how Israel's state institutions operate, who leads them, and who they actually answer to.
If you want to understand why Israel feels so politically fractured right now, you have to look past the daily headlines and examine the structural changes Netanyahu engineered across the judiciary, the civil service, the media, and the security establishment. Also making headlines in related news: Stop Falling for the Political Outrage Trap Every Time Vivek Ramaswamy Drops an Ad.
The Myth of the Reluctant Reformer
A common misconception is that Netanyahu’s clash with Israel's democratic guardrails started in January 2023, when his justice minister Yariv Levin unveiled the controversial judicial overhaul plan. That's backwards. The 2023 push was the climax of a strategy Netanyahu had been building since his second term began in 2009.
In the 1990s, during his first stint as prime minister, Netanyahu actually defended the Supreme Court's independence. He viewed a strong judiciary as essential for protecting minority rights and keeping the executive branch honest. Something changed after he returned to office in 2009, and it accelerated dramatically once police investigations into his personal conduct began in 2016. Additional details regarding the matter are explored by Reuters.
Suddenly, the "gatekeepers"—a term Israelis use for the Attorney General, the State Comptroller, Supreme Court justices, and senior civil servants—weren't seen as neutral referees. Netanyahu reframed them as an unelected "deep state" actively subverting the will of right-wing voters. Once that narrative took hold among his base, dismantling institutional checks stopped looking like self-preservation and started looking like populism.
Weakening the Civil Service and Ministries
If you've ever worked around government ministries in Jerusalem, you know that professional civil servants used to hold immense sway. Directors-general of ministries were typically career experts who stayed across different administrations, ensuring policy continuity and pushing back when ministers proposed legally shaky or economically reckless ideas.
Netanyahu systematically eroded that professional buffer.
- Politicizing key appointments: Under his governments, loyalty increasingly outweighed expertise when filling top bureaucratic roles. Professional civil service search committees were bypassed, watered down, or stacked with political allies.
- Fragmenting ministries: To keep fragile coalitions alive, Netanyahu carved up existing ministries into smaller, overlapping offices. Look at the 2020 and 2022 governments, where entire new ministries were invented out of thin air—like the Ministry of Settlements and National Missions or split portfolios within the Defense Ministry. This diluted the authority of veteran bureaucrats and made coordinated governance nearly impossible.
- Sidelining the State Comptroller: For decades, the State Comptroller was a fierce, independent watchdog feared by politicians. In 2019, Netanyahu backed Matanyahu Englman for the role—the first non-judge to hold the position in over thirty years. Critics, including former senior officials in the Comptroller's own office, pointed out that investigative reports into executive failures became noticeably softer afterward.
When you hollow out the civil service, you don't just get worse policy. You remove the internal friction that stops a prime minister from concentrating power.
The Long Campaign Against the Judiciary
Israel doesn't have a formal written constitution. Instead, it relies on a set of Basic Laws and an assertive Supreme Court to protect civil liberties and check government overreach. For decades, that balance held, even when right-wing and left-wing politicians grumbled about judicial activism.
Netanyahu's approach shifted from grumbling to delegitimization.
Following his 2019 indictment on charges of bribery, fraud, and breach of trust, the rhetoric escalated. Netanyahu stood outside the Jerusalem District Court in May 2020, surrounded by Likud ministers, and accused the police, the state prosecution, and the media of orchestrating an attempted coup against him. That single moment shattered a long-standing taboo in Israeli politics. A sitting prime minister was openly telling millions of citizens that the legal system itself was corrupt.
Then came the 2023 judicial overhaul. The proposed legislation aimed to strip the Supreme Court of its ability to strike down Basic Laws, hand the ruling coalition decisive control over judicial appointments, and weaken the authority of government legal advisors. Even though the October 7 Hamas attacks forced the government to freeze the most aggressive bills, the damage to public trust was already done. The Supreme Court struck down the "reasonableness" law in January 2024 by a razor-thin 8-7 majority, a ruling that underscored just how deeply polarized even the bench had become.
Reshaping the Media Landscape
You can't reshape state institutions without changing how the public hears about them. Netanyahu understood this better than any Israeli politician of his generation.
For years, Israel's media ecosystem was dominated by legacy outlets like Haaretz, Yedioth Ahronoth, and the public broadcaster. Netanyahu viewed them as inherently hostile. Rather than just complaining about bias, he helped alter the market itself.
The launch of Israel Hayom in 2007, backed by the late American billionaire Sheldon Adelson, changed everything. Distributed for free across the country, it quickly became Israel's most-read newspaper, offering consistently favorable coverage of Netanyahu while undercutting the financial model of traditional papers. Later, the rise of Channel 14—which evolved from a niche heritage channel into a fiercely pro-Netanyahu news network—gave the prime minister a direct, uncritical megaphone into Israeli living rooms.
At the same time, Netanyahu repeatedly moved to weaken or shut down the Israeli Public Broadcasting Corporation (Kan), arguing it was a waste of taxpayer money. While Kan survived thanks to pushback from coalition partners and international pressure, the constant threat of defunding kept journalists on the defensive.
The Security Establishment Wasn't Immune
Historically, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and intelligence agencies like Mossad and Shin Bet sat above partisan politics. Israelis trusted the military far more than they trusted politicians. Netanyahu carefully preserved a working relationship with security chiefs for years, often relying on their caution to temper more hawkish members of his cabinet.
That consensus fractured badly.
During the 2023 judicial crisis, thousands of military reservists—including elite fighter pilots and cyber intelligence officers—warned they would stop volunteering for duty if Israel ceased to be a liberal democracy. Instead of de-escalating, members of Netanyahu's coalition attacked the reservists as "anarchists" and "refuseniks," while Netanyahu himself accused top generals of trying to tie his hands.
After the catastrophic intelligence and operational failures of October 7, 2023, that rift widened into open hostility. While IDF Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi and Shin Bet director Ronen Bar publicly accepted responsibility for the failures on their watch, Netanyahu refused to do so, repeatedly shifting blame onto the security establishment in late-night social media posts and press briefings. By framing the military leadership as part of the same "elite" that opposed him, he breached the final wall separating Israeli partisan warfare from national defense.
Why This Matters Beyond Israel's Borders
If you follow global politics, Netanyahu’s playbook looks familiar. It shares clear DNA with how Viktor Orbán consolidated power in Hungary or how populist leaders in other democracies have chipped away at institutional checks without formally abolishing elections.
You don't need to cancel voting to transform a democracy. You just need to weaken the referees.
When legal advisors become political appointees, when state watchdogs lose their teeth, when public broadcasters fear for their budgets, and when voters are told the courts are their enemies, the formal shell of democracy remains intact while its substance hollows out.
How to Track What Happens Next
Whether Netanyahu remains in office for another year or exits the political stage tomorrow, Israel's institutions won't automatically snap back to their pre-2009 state. Institutional norms take decades to build and only a few years to dismantle.
If you want to cut through the noise and see whether Israel's democratic guardrails are recovering or eroding further, watch three specific indicators rather than daily political drama:
- The Judicial Selection Committee: Pay attention to who gets appointed to the Supreme Court as veteran justices retire. If the coalition manages to alter the committee's makeup to guarantee political loyalty over legal consensus, the court's role as an independent check is effectively over.
- The Attorney General's Status: Watch whether the government succeeds in splitting the Attorney General's role into separate advisory and prosecutorial offices, or makes ministerial legal advisors direct political hires. That single structural change would remove the primary legal brake on executive power.
- A State Commission of Inquiry: Keep an eye on whether an independent, judge-led state commission is finally formed to investigate the October 7 failures. A genuine inquiry holds the prime minister and the military equally accountable; a government-appointed committee signals that executive insulation has become permanent.