Stop Romanticizing Monsters Because They Learned How to Make Eye Contact

Stop Romanticizing Monsters Because They Learned How to Make Eye Contact

Journalists love a good character study. Give them a maximum-security visiting room, a plexiglass divider, and an inmate who answers questions without crying or snarling, and suddenly the pen starts leaking cheap empathy. We are treated to lingering reflections about curly hair, well-groomed appearances, and how an infamous killer looked right through the glass and seemed remarkably human.

Let us stop right there.

The lazy consensus in modern true-crime commentary is that if a murderer can hold a polite conversation two decades into a prison sentence, we must radically re-examine the tragedy of their lost potential. Commentators replay the old interviews, marvel at the polite tone, and ask whether society failed them first.

This is a category error of the highest order. It mistakes basic institutional survival skills for redemption.

When Christa Pike sat down for interviews years after brutally torturing and murdering 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer in 1995, she was not offering a window into a misunderstood soul. She was displaying the predictable adaptation of an individual who had spent years learning how to navigate a controlled environment. Psychopaths and sociopaths do not shed their core architecture because they reached middle age or learned how to write thank-you notes on purple paper. They learn the script. They figure out what interviewers want to hear—remorse, reflection, a wistful desire to have been a nurse—and they deliver the lines.

The media falls for it every single time because writers are desperate for narrative complexity where none exists.

Look at the hard data of human behavior rather than the soft theater of visiting-room pathos. Pike did not simply commit a horrific, premeditated murder as an 18-year-old—beating a teenager with asphalt and keeping a piece of her skull as a trophy. Years later, safely tucked inside a maximum-security institution, she attempted to kill another inmate with a shoelace. Let that anchor your perspective. The capacity for calculated, lethal violence did not evaporate with maturity; it simply waited for an opening.

When commentators hyperventilate over the state's clumsy mechanics of capital punishment or lament that a killer's life was prolonged, they miss the larger cultural sickness. We have developed an unhealthy cultural fetish for humanizing perpetrators at the direct expense of remembering victims. Colleen Slemmer does not get a multi-decade retrospective on how she might have evolved into a healthcare worker. Colleen got a patch of dirt in 1995 while her killers played out a slow-motion drama of appeals, media profiles, and institutional survival.

The obsession with finding the "good" or the "vulnerable child" inside an unrepentant predator is an intellectual indulgence. It requires ignoring the active, ongoing danger these individuals pose to anyone unlucky enough to share a cellblock with them.

True empathy is finite. When you spend it on someone who collected human bone fragments, you are stealing it from reality. Stop letting a clean appearance and a calm voice rewrite a butcher's ledger.

MG

Mason Green

Drawing on years of industry experience, Mason Green provides thoughtful commentary and well-sourced reporting on the issues that shape our world.